The Floating Island
(The Symphony of Ages universe; The Lost Journals of Ven Polypheme, Volume 1)
Elizabeth Haydon
Starscape
Fiction, Fantasy
*****
DESCRIPTION: In the long-lost Second Age of the world, two great books were written by one great man: the legendary Nain explorer Ven Polypheme, author of The Book of
All Human Knowledge and All Magical Things. Little is left of his personal life and records, but historians and scholars have labored long and hard to produce this
book, an account of his first-ever adventure and the beginning of his life of exploration.
Nains, diminutive long-lived people best known for their mines and their beards, mostly live underground, but some "upland" Nains live and work on the surface among humans and the
other races. Only one Nain family, the Polyphemes (founded by Magnus the Mad), inexplicably yet skillfully turned their talents to the crafting of seagoing ships. Charles Magnus
Ven Polypheme, better known as Ven, has just turned fifty (closer to twelve or thirteen by human standards), the youngest son of the Polypheme shipbuilder family. Unlike his
brothers, he loves the sea, just as he loves dreaming of what lays beyond the horizon and longs to learn everything there is to know about everywhere he can explore... which,
until now, has been mostly limited to his home town and his family's shipbuilding factory. Today, however, he is to take a newly-crafted vessel out for its Inspection before its
christening and sale, the first time he has been trusted with this all-important task. It's supposed to be a routine run around the bay, but things go wrong from the very start.
Soon, Ven finds himself all alone in a world far bigger, wilder, and more dangerous than he could ever imagine, wrapped up in a grand adventure involving sea people, Fire
Pirates, kings, and even terrors from beyond death... not to mention a magical floating island from the beginning of Time itself.
REVIEW: At first glance, this had all the trappings of a typical sea-fantasy adventure, but within the first few chapters it becomes readily apparent that Haydon takes
things far beyond "typical," integrating a great many fresh ideas into a genre which, in the wake of recent pirate-mania, is on the verge of being saturated. Ven makes a brave yet
human hero, willingly tackling almost every new task set before him even as he recognizes that his own insatiable curiosity can be more a danger than an asset - a nice change of
pace from some stories (who make their Reluctant Heroes so reluctant they'd never in a million years get past that to become a hero.) Haydon's races superficially resemble
classic humanoid races (Nains as Dwarves, others as Elves or Fairies, etc.), but even when she does use an existing mythical race (as the merrows, or merpeople), she gives them
enough life and originality to avoid easy comparison to others. As noted, this book uses Haydon's pre-existing Symphony of Ages universe, though these adventures in the "Second
Age" predate her other works. If you're unfamiliar with her other books, though, it shouldn't affect an outsider's enjoyment - when I read this book, I was completely unfamiliar
with Haydon's previous works, and it was through The Floating Island that my curiosity was sufficiently piqued to track them down. This is a very enjoyable book, the start
of a series I eagerly look forward to following.
Incidentally, the cover features, quite prominently, a sea dragon. Sea dragons are mentioned in passing, but never does Ven actually meet one. Under normal circumstances I'd be
upset, but I enjoyed the story too much to care. Besides, there's at least one more book in the works; I highly suspect Ven be exploring more wonders above and beneath the waves
then.
You might also enjoy:
The True Confessions of Charlotte Doyle (Avi, YA Fiction - A wealthy girl is accused of murder on the high seas)
The Lost Years of Merlin (T. A. Barron, YA Fiction - A boy with frightening magical gifts must learn to master them to face his destiny)
Faerie Wars (Herbie Brennan, YA Fiction - After finding a faerie prince in the garden, a boy finds himself on a dangerous adventure across multiple worlds)
The Throwaway Princess (Elinor Busby, YA Fiction - An exiled princess must save her land)
Furies of Calderon (Jim Butcher, Fiction - A farm boy in a magical world, but lacking gifts of his own, may be the only one who can save his people)
The Dragon and the George (George R. Dickson, Fiction - A man sets out to find his missing wife, and ends up trapped in another time in a dragon's body)
Dragonsdale (Salamanda Drake, YA Fiction - Born and raised in the family dragon riding academy, a girl is forbidden to fly herself)
Knight's Castle (Edward Eager, YA Fiction - A careless wish sets four kids up for a magical adventure)
Pawn of Prophecy (David Eddings, Fiction - A farmboy finds himself on an epic quest)
Magician: Apprentice (Raymond E. Feist, Fiction - An orphan boy in a frontier castle faces otherworldly armies)
The Stoneheart trilogy (Charlie Fletcher, YA Fiction - After breaking a stone carving, a London boy is pulled into the invisible war between the city's statues and gargoyles)
Dragon Rider (Cornelia Funke, YA Fiction - A young dragon sets out to find a legendary sanctuary, with an irascible brownie and an orphaned boy)
Fly By Night (Frances Hardinge, YA Fiction - An orphaned girl and her pet goose find themselves caught up in a dark plot)
Song in the Silence (Elizabeth Kerner, YA Fiction - A girl dreams of meeting legendary dragons, while a dragon dreams of meeting a human girl)
The Piratica series (Tanith Lee, YA Fiction - In an alternate Earth, a bold girl takes to the seas as a pirate queen)
The Bloody Jack series (L. A. Meyer, YA Fiction - An orphaned girl leaves the streets of London behind by posing as a boy aboard a sailing ship)
Merlin's Mistake (Robert Newman, YA Fiction - A boy eager for adventure sets out on a quest to find the lost wizard Merlin)
Tamora Pierce's books (Tamora Pierce, YA Fiction - Adventurous tales of young men and women set in well-realized magical worlds)
Larklight (Philip Reeve, YA Fiction - In a Victorian-era space adventure, two British children embark upon a singular adventure through the aether of space)
The Kingkiller Chronicle (Patrick Rothfuss, Fiction - A living legend, now hiding behind a pseudonym as a quiet innkeeper, relates the story of a young life gone wrong)
Treasure Island (Robert Louis Stevenson, YA Fiction - An English boy finds himself caught up in the hunt for a dead pirate's treasure)
The Hobbit (J. R. R. Tolkien, YA? Fiction - A humble hobbit is thrust into an ill-advised journey to a dragon's lair)
The 100 Cupboards trilogy (N. D. Wilson, YA Fiction - A boy finds magical cupboards to other worlds)
The Dragonback Adventures (Timothy Zahn, YA Fiction - A fugitive boy thief and a dragonlike alien form an unlikely alliance)
Return to Top of Page - Return to Book Review List
The Thief Queen's Daughter
(Symphony of Ages universe; The Lost Journals of Ven Polypheme, Volume 2)
Elizabeth Haydon
Starscape
Fiction, Fantasy
****
DESCRIPTION: Ven Polypheme, the Nain boy adventurer, has just received his first assignment as Royal Reporter to the young King Vandemere of Serendair. The king's father received a mysterious object before his untimely death, a glowing stone in a riddle-inscribed box, but what the stone is and who gave it to the king nobody seems to know. To find the answers, Ven and his friends from the Crossroads Inn must venture into the Gated City, a former penal colony wherein felons and their descendents trade in all manner of strange and magical things, from enchanted armor to stolen childhoods... and where the ill-rumored Thief Queen of the Raven Clan holds sway. The Gated City is a place of wonders beyond compare, and dangers beyond reckoning; has Ven's insatiable curiosity finally gotten him and his friends in too deep?
REVIEW: A fairly fun and fast-moving story, much like Ven's first adventure, picks up fairly quickly and keeps moving. For some reason, I found the loose ends - setups, clearly, for Ven's future adventures, which will extend for at least one more book - more blatant, and something about the resolution felt a bit too neat and quick after all he and his friends went through getting there. Also, like the first book, a dragon features rather prominently on the cover. While this book at least mentions dragons in some remotely story-related context, it has no more reason to star a dragon on the cover than the first book did; the third book sounds like it deals with an actual dragon, but it's still a bit irksome. I still enjoyed it, but marginally less than Haydon's first Polypheme book; I'm still looking forward to Ven's next adventure, but this time I'll wait for paperback.
You might also enjoy:
The True Confessions of Charlotte Doyle (Avi, YA Fiction - A wealthy girl is accused of murder on the high seas)
The Lost Years of Merlin (T. A. Barron, YA Fiction - A boy with frightening magical gifts must learn to master them to face his destiny)
Faerie Wars (Herbie Brennan, YA Fiction - After finding a faerie prince in the garden, a boy finds himself on a dangerous adventure across multiple worlds)
The Throwaway Princess (Elinor Busby, YA Fiction - An exiled princess must save her land)
Furies of Calderon (Jim Butcher, Fiction - A farm boy in a magical world, but lacking gifts of his own, may be the only one who can save his people)
The Dragon and the George (George R. Dickson, Fiction - A man sets out to find his missing wife, and ends up trapped in another time in a dragon's body)
Dragonsdale (Salamanda Drake, YA Fiction - Born and raised in the family dragon riding academy, a girl is forbidden to fly herself);
Knight's Castle (Edward Eager, YA Fiction - A careless wish sets four kids up for a magical adventure)
Pawn of Prophecy (David Eddings, Fiction - A boy finds himself on an epic quest);
Magician: Apprentice (Raymond E. Feist, Fiction - An orphan boy in a frontier castle faces otherworldly armies)
The Stoneheart trilogy (Charlie Fletcher, YA Fiction - After breaking a stone carving, a London boy is pulled into the invisible war between the city's statues and gargoyles)
Dragon Rider (Cornelia Funke, YA Fiction - A young dragon sets out to find a legendary sanctuary, with an irascible brownie and an orphaned boy)
Fly By Night (Frances Hardinge, YA Fiction - An orphaned girl and her pet goose find themselves caught up in a dark plot)
Song in the Silence (Elizabeth Kerner, YA Fiction - A girl dreams of meeting legendary dragons, while a dragon dreams of meeting a human girl)
The Piratica series (Tanith Lee, YA Fiction - In an alternate Earth, a bold girl takes to the seas as a pirate queen)
The Bloody Jack series (L. A. Meyer, YA Fiction - An orphaned girl leaves the streets of London behind by posing as a boy aboard a sailing ship)
Merlin's Mistake (Robert Newman, YA Fiction - A boy eager for adventure sets out on a quest to find the lost wizard Merlin)
Tamora Pierce's books (Tamora Pierce, YA Fiction - Adventurous tales of young men and women set in well-realized magical worlds)
Larklight (Philip Reeve, YA Fiction - In a Victorian-era space adventure, two British children embark upon a singular adventure through the aether of space)
The Kingkiller Chronicle (Patrick Rothfuss, Fiction - A living legend, now hiding behind a pseudonym as a quiet innkeeper, relates the story of a young life gone wrong)
Treasure Island (Robert Louis Stevenson, YA Fiction - An English boy finds himself caught up in the hunt for a dead pirate's treasure)
The Hobbit (J. R. R. Tolkien, YA? Fiction - A humble hobbit is thrust into an ill-advised journey to a dragon's lair)
The 100 Cupboards trilogy (N. D. Wilson, YA Fiction - A boy finds magical cupboards to other worlds)
The Dragonback Adventures (Timothy Zahn, YA Fiction - A fugitive boy thief and a dragonlike alien form an unlikely alliance)
Return to Top of Page - Return to Book Review List
Rhapsody
(Symphony of Ages series; Rhapsody trilogy, Book 1)
Elizabeth Haydon
Tor
Fiction, Fantasy
*****
DESCRIPTION: Rhapsody, a half-Lirin woman with a long, painful past mostly of her own making, is a gifted Singer, able to use her voice and music to enhance or alter
the vibrational patterns of the world around her - in essence, to work magic. Studying for the rank of Namer, a Singer powerful enough to rename and thus remake an entity's
energy, her teacher vanishes just as an old enemy from her darker days returns.
The Brother was born an assassin, member of a fading elder race whose very existence was dedicated to wiping out the evil, fireborn demons known as the F'nor, among the first
species ever to walk the earth. By a cruel twist of fate, the Brother now serves a F'nor-bound master, an evil man who stole his name and with it his freedom. He and his giant
Bolg assistant Grunthor were fleeing their latest dire task, a task too heinous even for his hardened heart, when they run into Rhapsody... a chance encounter that gives Brother
the freedom he has longed for yet puts them all in greater danger than ever.
What started as a simple flight from mutual and separate pursuers quickly turns into something much greater. The three reluctant allies find themselves on an epic journey across
the known world, down the Roots of the earth, and even through the fiery heart of the planet itself, a journey that will take them countless miles and centuries away from
everything they have ever known... and, perhaps, bring them at last to where they truly belong.
REVIEW: Having first "met" Haydon when I read The Floating Island, I tracked down this book, the first in her Symphony of Ages series, to see if it used
the same wondrous world. Happily, it does. It's a very good sign when the first paragraph of a story hooks you into a solid day or more of reading. Haydon creates not just the
usual continent-and-coastline world of fantasy epics, but an entire planet full of mingling and clashing races, cultures, and histories. The races she builds and the story she
tells have roots in standard fantasy fare, but grow far beyond that, easily taking on rich lives of their own. Only one character irritated me, and she was introduced fairly
late in the game; she might redeem herself in future installments. Hopefully, I won't have to wait too long before I acquire some manner of book budget and can begin tracking
down the next books.
(I have the second book in the trilogy, but for some reason I keep stalling out when trying to read it; her characters get more stubbornly obtuse and self-pitying, and the
irritating one dominates more plot time. Still, I love the universe enough that I hope to plow through someday - maybe I just need to back up and take a fresh run at it...)
You might also enjoy:
The Sword of Shannara (Terry Brooks, Fiction - A boy learns he might be the only one able to stop a great evil from overtaking the world)
The Vlad Taltos series (Stephen Brust, Fiction - A finely crafted world serves as the backdrop for stories of a clever assassin and his dragonlike familiar)
The Crown of Stars series (Kate Elliot, Fiction - Political unrest and inhuman raiders presage a greater evil)
Magician: Apprentice (Raymond E. Feist, Fiction - An orphan boy in a frontier castle faces otherworldly armies)
The Sword of Truth series (Terry Goodkind, Fiction - A cranky wizard, a woodland guide, and a mysterious woman face terrible dark forces)
Dune (Frank Herbert, Fiction - The interstellar human civilization relies on life-extending spice from desert Arrakis)
Any of Robin Hobb's fantasy series (Robin Hobb, Fiction - Well-crafted fantasy tales in well-crafted worlds)
The Tough Guide to Fantasyland (Diana Wynne Jones, Fiction - A humorous tour guide to epic fantasy worlds)
The Wheel of Time series (Robert Jordan, Fiction - Evil awakes and threatens a peaceful realm)
A Song of Ice and Fire series (George R. R. Martin, Fiction - World-spanning epic tale of wars and kings, good and evil, and a few dragons for good measure)
Tortall quartets (Tamora Pierce, YA Fiction - Tales of adventure in a magical world)
The Kingkiller Chronicle (Patrick Rothfuss, Fiction - A living legend, now hiding behind a pseudonym as a quiet innkeeper, relates the story of a young life gone wrong)
The Mistborn trilogy (Brandon Sanderson, Fiction - A homeless thief girl with an unusual gift is recruited to help topple the immortal Lord Ruler's cruel empire)
The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings trilogy (J. R. R. Tolkien, Fiction - The classic epic tale of Hobbits, Elves, Men, wizards, and Middle-Earth)
The Death Gate Cycle (Margaret Weis and Tracy Hickman, Fiction - An epic fantasy spanning seven worlds)
The Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn trilogy (Tad Williams, Fiction - The magical land of Osten Ard faces an ancient evil)
The Shadowmarch series (Tad Williams, Fiction - The Eddon twins, Prince Barrick and Princess Briony, stand between the threat of faerie Qar to the north and the brutal god-king Autarch to the south)
Return to Top of Page - Return to Book Review List
Prophecy
(Symphony of Ages series; Rhapsody trilogy, Book 2)
Elizabeth Haydon
Tor
Fiction, Fantasy
***
DESCRIPTION: The half-Lirin woman Rhapsody and her companions, the brutish giant Grunthor and the former assassin Achmed, are refugees from a land and a time
swallowed by centuries. Unfortunately, an ancient evil, the one that destroyed their homeland of Serendair centuries ago, has also come halfway around the world to
continue its quest for complete chaos and destruction. As Achmed and Grunthor continue building their Bolg kingdom in the abandoned subterranean city of the late King
Gwylliam (once a shining beacon of hope for the displaced - and immortal - first generation Serendair refuguees, but now a curse after his actions destroyed the very
land he once united), Rhapsody sets out into the world of Men to follow her own path. Her often-prophetic nightmares warn her that the evil demon plots against a
religious leader, but her efforts to save the man are complicated. The demon acts most often through a host, who can be entirely unaware of the dark influence compelling
their actions... and thus impossible to track until it is too late. She also keeps crossing paths with the handsome, mysterious man known as Ashe, whose tormented past
is as shrouded as his motivations. In a land full of secrets and lies, Ashe could be a powerful ally - or an enemy as terrible as the demon itself.
As Rhapsody pursues the demon's agents and works to thwart its plans, King Achmed and Grunthor discover a long-lost secret beneath the mountains that not even the great
architect Gwylliam found... and, with it, more clues to the prophecies that might save the world - or see it consumed in demonic fire.
REVIEW: I have a few books running around that managed to lose themselves after I started reading them; recent reorganization efforts unearthed them, and I've
been slowly picking my way through them. This book is one of them, so perhaps my rating should be taken with a slight grain of salt. What I loved about the first book
in this series (Rhapsody) was the wonderfully realized world - not just a continent, not just a short span of years, but an entire globe, peopled with disparate
cultures and races that merge and break through the centuries - Haydon created. Here, she continues the process, but I found my interest waning as my eyes glazed, with
large chunks of information interrupting the flow of the story. Her characters, intriguing in the first volume, start to feel strained as she develops them further.
Actually, it was the heroine Rhapsody and her significant friend Ashe who nearly whined me out of finishing the book, going to elaborate, nearly comical lengths to
bemoan and bewail their Tragic Pasts and Deep Dark Secrets. Once their relationship kindles (as expected), they bemoan and bewail even in their happiness.
The story, when it moves, does at least move quickly, and when Rhapsody and her friends actually do learn something (instead of dancing around it or taking history
lesson breaks), they tend to act on it in a reasonably intelligent manner. Those moments seemed to be a bit thin, given the overall length of the book... and Haydon
still has (at least) one more to go to wrap things up. By this point, though, I'm starting to wonder how much of the third book will be world-building and character-
whining padding as opposed to actual story. Still some nice ideas in there, and still an impressive world, but I just had to push myself too hard to keep reading to
merit a Good rating. I'm not sure I have the reading stamina to wade through much more. (The third volume in the trilogy, Destiny, is sitting in my reading backlog
as I type, but I don't expect I'll be getting to it soon.)
You might also enjoy:
The Sword of Shannara (Terry Brooks, Fiction - A boy learns he might be the only one able to stop a great evil from overtaking the world)
The Vlad Taltos series (Stephen Brust, Fiction - A finely crafted world serves as the backdrop for stories of a clever assassin and his dragonlike familiar)
The Crown of Stars series (Kate Elliot, Fiction - Political unrest and inhuman raiders presage a greater evil)
Magician: Apprentice (Raymond E. Feist, Fiction - An orphan boy in a frontier castle faces otherworldly armies)
The Sword of Truth series (Terry Goodkind, Fiction - A cranky wizard, a woodland guide, and a mysterious woman face terrible dark forces)
Dune (Frank Herbert, Fiction - The interstellar human civilization relies on life-extending spice from desert Arrakis)
Any of Robin Hobb's fantasy series (Robin Hobb, Fiction - Well-crafted fantasy tales in well-crafted worlds)
The Tough Guide to Fantasyland (Diana Wynne Jones, Fiction - A humorous tour guide to epic fantasy worlds)
The Wheel of Time series (Robert Jordan, Fiction - Evil awakes and threatens a peaceful realm)
A Song of Ice and Fire series (George R. R. Martin, Fiction - World-spanning epic tale of wars and kings, good and evil, and a few dragons for good measure)
Tortall quartets (Tamora Pierce, YA Fiction - Tales of adventure in a magical world)
The Kingkiller Chronicle (Patrick Rothfuss, Fiction - A living legend, now hiding behind a pseudonym as a quiet innkeeper, relates the story of a young life gone wrong)
The Mistborn trilogy (Brandon Sanderson, Fiction - A homeless thief girl with an unusual gift is recruited to help topple the immortal Lord Ruler's cruel empire)
The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings trilogy (J. R. R. Tolkien, Fiction - The classic epic tale of Hobbits, Elves, Men, wizards, and Middle-Earth)
The Death Gate Cycle (Margaret Weis and Tracy Hickman, Fiction - An epic fantasy spanning seven worlds)
The Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn trilogy (Tad Williams, Fiction - The magical land of Osten Ard faces an ancient evil)
The Shadowmarch series (Tad Williams, Fiction - The Eddon twins, Prince Barrick and Princess Briony, stand between the threat of faerie Qar to the north and the brutal god-king Autarch to the south)
Return to Top of Page - Return to Book Review List
Return to Brightdreamer Books Home
Brightdreamer Books is created and maintained by TBW, a.k.a. "Brightdreamer."
E-mail: tbweber AT comcast DOT net. (Remove spaces, replace AT with "@" and DOT with "." - please put "Brightdreamer Books" in the subject line, or your e-mail may be deleted as
spam! Thank you!