Bone Wars
Brett Davis
Baen
Fiction, Sci-Fi
**
DESCRIPTION: In the late 1870's, rival paleontologists Edward Cope and O. C. Marsh work the barren Montana wilderness, hunting for fossils. The pickings are mighty slim, since a third man who calls himself Alf Swenson seems to be getting to them all first. He employs technology far in advance of anything available at the time: invisible walls, an odd metal "tent," and the ability to lift the fossils straight out of the rock without so much as a shovel. Another stranger, calling himself Greig, claims to be Swenson's rival, and both try to recruit Cope and Marsh against the other. It soon becomes apparent that Swenson and Greig are not of this world, and have their own motivations for wanting dinosaur bones. To complicate matters, the Sioux leader Sitting Bull is making a detour to the area for his own reasons, which has the resident Crow agitated.
REVIEW: After reading this, I wanted to ask, among other things, just why Davis felt compelled to write this story. Furthermore, why did he take Cope, Marsh, and
various other real-life historical figures, and throw them into a lousy sci-fi plot that never goes anywhere? Who knows? As a humble reader, I don't have a clue, even after
reading it. Some people have a knack for including actual people in alternate reality tales, but not Davis. Maybe if he'd just made up a couple of scientists and Indians, it
wouldn't have been as boring, but I doubt it. There just wasn't much to this book. None of the characters came across as real people, and all of the situations were forced. I
found the explanation rushed and entirely unsatisfactory. (I saw a sequel on the shelves, Two Tiny Claws, which drags P. T. Barnum into the unholy mess; this might explain
the lousy ending, but doesn't do much to redeem the book in the ratings.) I think it's going in with the next batch of books to sell to Half-Price Books, so I can save shelf
space for more deserving titles.
You might also enjoy:
Sky Coyote (Kage Baker, Fiction - A company from the future uses immortal cyborg agents to manipulate history for profit)
Frontier Earth (Bruce Boxleitner, Fiction - An amnesiac man in the Old West faces alien invaders)
Jurassic Park (Michael Crichton, Fiction - An experimental theme park uses DNA to create living dinosaurs)
The Lost World (Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, Fiction - A professor leads an expedition to a remote South American plateau, where prehistoric animals still roam)
Dinosaurs (Carl Mehling, editor, Nonfiction - Dinosaurs, pterosaurs, and other prehistoric animals)
Thunder Lizards! How to Draw Fantastic Dinosaurs (Steve Miller, YA? Art - How to draw dinosaurs)
The Illustrated Encyclopedia of Dinosaurs (Dr. David Norman, Nonfiction - Dinosaurs and other prehistoric beasts examined and explained)
The Temeraire series (Naomi Novik, Fiction - Alternate-history Napoleonic wars feature sapient dragons harnessed as aerial fighting forces)
Devil's Tower and Devil's Engine (Mark Sumner, Fiction - The rise of magic after the Civil War forever alters America's westward expansion)
Pterosaurs: The Illustrated Encyclopedia of Flying Reptiles (Dr. Peter Wellenhoffer, Nonfiction - A look at the many pterosaurs of the Dinosaur Age)
Return to Top of Page - Return to Book Review List
Return to Brightdreamer Books Home
Brightdreamer Books is created and maintained by TBW, a.k.a. "Brightdreamer."
E-mail: tbweber AT comcast DOT net. (Remove spaces, replace AT with "@" and DOT with "." - please put "Brightdreamer Books" in the subject line, or your e-mail may be deleted as
spam! Thank you!