Gregor the Overlander
(The Underland Chronicles, Book 1)
Suzanne Collins
Scholastic
Fiction, YA Fiction
***+
DESCRIPTION: Two years, seven months, and thirteen days ago, Gregor's father disappeared without a trace. In New York City, people vanish all the time, for all
sorts of reasons. Some of them fall in with the wrong crowd, or simply don't want to be found. Gregor knows that's not the case. His dad would never leave him, his sisters,
his mother, or his grandmother. Sure, they weren't exactly living in a Park Avenue penthouse, but he loved Gregor, and Gregor loved him. As soon as Dad comes home,
he'll...
But Gregor won't let himself think about that, won't let himself think of hope or happiness, for fear of jinxing his father's return. In the meantime, all he can do is help
out as best he can around the house. With Grandma's senility, Mom struggling to stretch one income over so many mouths to feed, and his two-year-old sister Boots' constant
need for supervision and diaper changes, there's more than enough to do to keep his mind occupied. Even doing laundry is a blessing. At least, until Boots worked loose the
latch on the grate in the laundry room. As Gregor races to keep her out of the walls, the two fall in... and down.
Suddenly, Gregor and Boots find themselves in a strange, dark world, where giant cockroaches, spiders, rats, and more live in an uneasy truce with humans and bats. The people
of the Underland have many prophecies left by their long-lost progenitor - prophecies that may concern Gregor himself. Gregor only wants to return home, where his mother must
be frantic... until he learns that he isn't the first human to tumble into the Underland. The last "Overlander" to survive the plunge came through precisely two years, seven
months, and thirteen days ago.
Gregor's father. Still alive.
REVIEW: Gregor the Overlander mixes some nicely original "otherland" twists with a strangely bland story. The title character tends to think in obvious
blocks of text (annoyingly set off in quote marks), holding the reader's hand as though not trusting them to follow the tale through its darker stretches. As with
many "otherland" tales, Gregor's New York City street smarts and ability to comprehend slang terminology gives him an edge on the Underlanders, though they prove quite adept
at surviving in their own harsh world, with a matter-of-fact survival instinct that perpetually eludes him. Gregor's adventures in the Underland start out fairly benign, as he
is protected from the brutality of Underland survival by having the good fortune to travel with people who do the hard work for him. The fact that he's named in a prophecy only
heightens his security. Even when death and destruction come crashing down upon him, I felt oddly detached from the action, with only an occasional emotional connection breaking
through. I can't say precisely why; maybe it was the writing style, or the way Gregor tended to explain his thoughts and emotions instead of feeling them. Boots, his traveling
companion, actually has a purpose on the journey, though I do rather wish Collins had aged her a few years: I've never been particularly fond of pushy toddlers. (I'm also not
entirely sure that Boots wasn't the reason for my sense of detatchment - Gregor spends so much energy protecting her from the hard edges of the Underland that his own
experiences seemed equally bubble-wrapped for most of the story.) The author gets marks, however, for using a tantrum as a sonic weapon, perhaps the most unique use of a
two-year-old I've ever encountered. Collins also establishes different morality codes for the different species of Underland; one of Gregor's great struggles is how he must come
to accept that not everyone here thinks like a human, nor can they be expected to do so. Almost despite itself, Gregor's quest builds to a violent climax, though most of the
violence occurs offscreen and is only witnessed in its aftermath. The very end teases of more adventures to come for Gregor and Boots.
In the end, while the book had its moments, I couldn't find the energy or interest to push it to a solid Good rating. I don't expect I'll follow the rest of this series.
You might also enjoy:
The Everworld series (K. A. Applegate, YA Fiction - Four Chicago teens are pulled into a world of magic and elder gods)
Peter Pan (James M. Barrie, YA Fiction - The boy who won't grow up lures three English children to Neverland, where imagination is real)
The Wizard of Oz (L. Frank Baum, YA Fiction - A tornado drops young Dorothy and her dog Toto in the magical world of Oz)
The Inscription (Pam Binder, Fiction - A modern woman travels back in time via Loch Ness, where she may be part of an immortal prophecy)
Faerie Wars (Herbie Brennan, YA Fiction - A boy finds a faerie prince in the garden and becomes entangled in an interdimensional war)
Magic Kingdom For Sale - Sold! (Terry Brooks, Fiction - A burnt-out lawyer buys a magical kingdom through a high-end gift catalog)
A Princess of Mars (Edgar Rice Burroughs, Fiction - A Civil War veteran finds himself on the dying, hostile planet Mars)
Dragon Companion (Don Callander, Fiction - A New York librarian finds himself inexplicably transported to a world of elves and dragons)
The Best of Lewis Carroll (Lewis Carrol, YA Fiction - Includes the tales of Alice and her adventures in Wonderland and Looking-Glass Land)
The Tale of Despereaux (Kate DiCamillo, YA Fiction - A brave mouse tries to save a human princess from a conniving rat's evil plot)
The Dragon and the George (George R. Dickson, Fiction - A modern man seeking his missing wife finds himself trapped in a dragon's body in a magical medieval world)
Coraline (Neil Gaiman, YA Fiction - A girl finds a little doorway to a mirror version of her flat, where a sinister "Other Mother" awaits)
Neverwhere (Neil Gaiman, Fiction - After helping a homeless girl, a man finds himself stuck in the shadowy realm of London Below)
The Dinotopia series (James Gurney, YA? Fiction - A professor and his son are shipwrecked on a lost world where humans coexist with prehistoric creatures)
The Chronicles of Narnia (C. S. Lewis, YA Fiction - Children from Earth visit the magical realm of Narnia, creation of the great Lion Aslan)
Pendragon: Merchant of Death (D. J. MacHale, YA Fiction - Helping an odd uncle, a boy finds himself in another world, helping defend the natives from a threatening force)
Un Lun Dun (China Miéville, YA Fiction - Two girls find the bizarre "abcity" mirror of London)
The Keys to the Kingdom: Mister Monday (Garth Nix, YA Fiction - A boy is given the keys to God's house, where chaos reigns and evil awaits)
The Chronicles of the Imaginarium Geographica (James A. Owen, YA Fiction - Three Englishmen travel to the Archipelago of Dreams, inspiration for story and myth since the dawn of time)
The Curious World of Shelley Vendor (Colin R. Parsons, YA Fiction - A clumsy girl follows alien book-thieves into a dangerous world)
The Diadem series (John Peel, YA Fiction - Three children are plucked from their worlds, bound by a powerful destiny)
The Amazing Maurice and his Educated Rodents (Terry Pratchett, Fiction - A con-artist cat running a rat plague con discovers a real problem under the city of Bad Blintz)
Jake Ransom and the Skull King's Shadow (James Rollins, YA Fiction - An artifact pulls a teen boy and his sister into a world of lost civilizations, living dinosaurs, and dangerous magic)
Shadowbloom (Justin Sullivan and Samuel Sullivan, YA Fiction - Following a vivid dream, twins find themselves pulled into a dark world where plants run amok)
The Iron Dragon's Daughter (Michael Swanwick, Fiction - Abducted into the fairy world as a child, a girl seeks escape and vengeance with a mechanical war dragon)
The War of the Flowers (Tad Williams, Fiction - A man is taken to the fairy world, where magic parallels technology)
The 100 Cupboards trilogy (N. D. Wilson, Fiction - A boy discovers magical doorways to other worlds, where he accidentally unleashes an undead evil)
The Castle in the Attic and The Battle for the Castle (Elizabeth Winthrop, YA Fiction - The toy castle in a boy's attic is a gateway to a real magical land)
Return to Top of Page - Return to Book Review List
Return to Brightdreamer Books Home
Brightdreamer Books is created and maintained by TBW, a.k.a. "Brightdreamer."
E-mail: tbweber AT comcast DOT net. (Remove spaces, replace AT with "@" and DOT with "." - please put "Brightdreamer Books" in the subject line, or your e-mail may be deleted as
spam! Thank you!